Two gold bars can display a similar percentage premium and still end up with different final costs. A good comparison begins with the same weight of fine gold, the same payment method, and a quote timestamp, then finishes with total delivery and resale assumptions. This worksheet helps you compare like with like without relying on a made-up current gold price.
Record the quote before it expires
For each dealer, write down the product description, mint or refiner, purity, unit weight, quantity, quoted spot reference, timestamp and payment method. A quote for a 10-ounce bar is not interchangeable with ten one-ounce coins: both may represent about ten troy ounces of gold, but fabrication costs, sale flexibility and resale terms differ.
Use this comparison table
| Field | Dealer A | Dealer B |
|---|---|---|
| Exact product and quantity | ______ | ______ |
| Fine troy ounces in the order | ______ | ______ |
| Quoted spot per fine troy ounce | ______ | ______ |
| Quoted merchandise price | ______ | ______ |
| Shipping and insured delivery | ______ | ______ |
| Payment or card surcharge | ______ | ______ |
| Applicable tax and other charges | ______ | ______ |
| Total delivered order price | ______ | ______ |
| Dealer's documented buyback bid | ______ | ______ |
| Assay, shipping or settlement conditions | ______ | ______ |
Premium dollars = delivered purchase cost minus (fine troy ounces × quoted spot). Premium percentage = premium dollars ÷ reference melt value × 100. If metal weight or the quoted spot benchmark differs, normalize first or the comparison is misleading.
A worked example using hypothetical numbers
Suppose a dealer quotes a one-ounce item at $4,180 when the comparison spot reference is $4,000. Insured delivery adds $20 and there is no other charge. Total paid is $4,200, a hypothetical $200 premium over that spot reference, or 5%. This is an arithmetic example, not a current dealer offer.
Now suppose a different dealer's all-in price would be $4,165 for the same quantity and condition. Its arithmetic premium is $165 or 4.125%, but you should still compare payment rules, delivery timing and the ability to return or sell the exact item. The lowest delivered price is not always the lowest total risk.
Why the buyback bid belongs on the same sheet
A dealer can sell bullion above spot while bidding below spot to buy it back. The difference is part of the round-trip spread. Your actual resale result also depends on future metal prices, condition, assay needs, shipping and dealer policy. Do not mistake a retailer's sales price for a guaranteed resale value.
Our how-to-sell-gold guide covers bid collection and settlement risks. For larger orders, ask whether the seller's advertised volume price actually applies at the quantity you want and whether an order changes once availability is confirmed.
What about fractional coins and large bars?
Fractional pieces may provide convenient smaller resale units but frequently carry a higher fabrication and distribution cost per fine ounce. Larger bars can reduce percentage premium at purchase but are indivisible, and a seller may face different verification needs. Compare our fractional gold guide and gold premiums explainer before interpreting a quoted difference as pure savings.
Final dealer checklist
- Verify the merchant's exact legal business identity, contact methods, settlement rules and delivery insurance.
- Check whether spot and price are locked at order placement, payment receipt or shipment.
- Confirm what happens if inventory changes or payment clearance is delayed.
- Ask for a written shipping and loss policy, especially on large orders.
- Separate dealer promotional claims from independent specifications.
- Keep receipts and the documented product description for future resale.
When you're ready to compare real numbers, use the premium calculator and the site's existing dealer review pages. Those links are research starting points, not guarantees of stock, attribution or future value.