Counterfeit gold exists, and the better fakes are made by people who know exactly which tests buyers run. The good news is that most fakes fail at least one simple, non-destructive check, and the strongest protection of all is buying from an established dealer with a clear return policy. This guide covers the checks you can do at home without scratching, cutting or acid-testing your gold, and explains what each test can and can't prove.
Never use acid tests, files or drills on bullion you intend to resell. Damaged coins and bars can sell for less, and many dealers will refuse items that have been cut or scratched.
Start with the source
The single biggest predictor of counterfeit risk is where you bought. Purchases from established online dealers and authorized distributors carry far less risk than private sales, online marketplaces, or "too good to be true" deals. If a price is meaningfully below what reputable dealers charge for the same product, assume something is wrong. Our dealer comparison guide explains how to benchmark prices.
The reference specs you need
Every test below compares your item with a known specification. Get the spec from the issuing mint or refiner, not from the seller.
| Coin (1 oz) | Purity | Approx. gross weight | Approx. diameter |
|---|---|---|---|
| American Gold Eagle | .9167 | 33.93 g | 32.70 mm |
| American Gold Buffalo | .9999 | 31.11 g | 32.70 mm |
| Krugerrand | .9167 | 33.93 g | 32.77 mm |
| Gold Philharmonic | .9999 | 31.10 g | 37.0 mm |
U.S. coin figures are from the U.S. Mint. For bars, the refiner's published dimensions for that product are the reference.
Test 1: Weight
A digital scale that reads to 0.01 g is inexpensive and the best first test. A genuine coin should be very close to its specification. A large deviation is a red flag; a tiny one is normal within mint tolerances.
Limit: weight alone can be faked. Tungsten has almost the same density as gold, so a well-made tungsten-core fake can hit the right weight.
Test 2: Dimensions
Digital calipers measure diameter and thickness. Because gold is so dense, a fake made of a lighter metal at the right weight must be thicker or wider. Weight plus dimensions together catch most cheap fakes.
Limit: tungsten-core fakes are designed to pass both tests.
Test 3: Magnet
Gold is not magnetic. A strong neodymium magnet that grabs a coin means it contains iron, nickel or cobalt. Slide the magnet near a coin on an angled surface; real gold may slow very slightly from induced currents but will not stick.
Limit: passing a magnet test proves little, since tungsten, lead, copper and many other metals are also non-magnetic.
Test 4: The ring (ping) test
Balance a coin on a fingertip and tap it gently with another coin. Genuine gold coins produce a characteristic sustained ring. Many fakes sound dull. Smartphone apps can compare the frequency against known coins.
Limit: it works best on coins, not bars, and takes practice. Capsules must be removed. Results are suggestive, not conclusive.
Test 5: Specific gravity
This compares an item's weight in air with its weight when suspended in water to calculate density. Pure gold has a density of about 19.3 g/cm³; 22-karat alloys are lower. It's accurate for solid items but requires careful technique.
Limit: tungsten's density (about 19.25 g/cm³) is very close to pure gold's, so specific gravity alone can't rule out a tungsten core.
Test 6: Visual inspection
Compare the coin with high-resolution images from the mint for that year. Look at lettering, rims, reeding, fine design details and finish. Modern security features, such as the Royal Mint's tilt-effect elements on recent Britannias, help. For bars, check the refiner's logo, font, serial number format and assay card, and see assay card vs no assay for what documentation does and doesn't prove.
Limit: skilled counterfeiters copy details well. Visual checks catch sloppy fakes.
Test 7: Electronic testers (professional or prosumer)
- Electromagnetic and resistivity testers measure electrical properties below the surface and are effective against plated and some core-type fakes. Many bullion dealers use them.
- Ultrasonic thickness gauges can detect internal inconsistencies in bars.
- XRF (X-ray fluorescence) analyzers read surface composition accurately but don't see deep inside; thick plating can fool them.
Most individuals don't need to own these; a reputable dealer or assayer can test for you.
How the tests combine
| Test | Catches | Misses |
|---|---|---|
| Weight | Wrong-metal fakes at wrong weight | Tungsten-core fakes |
| Dimensions | Lighter-metal fakes at correct weight | Tungsten-core fakes |
| Magnet | Steel, iron, nickel content | All non-magnetic fakes |
| Ring test | Many base-metal fakes | Some well-made fakes; bars |
| Specific gravity | Most fakes except tungsten | Tungsten cores |
| Electronic testers | Plating and many core fakes | Depends on tester depth |
No single home test is proof. Passing several reduces risk; failing any one is a reason to stop and get a professional opinion.
What to do if you suspect a fake
- Stop handling it beyond basic tests; don't damage it.
- Contact the seller with photos and your measurements. Established dealers have processes for this.
- Get a second opinion from a reputable dealer or assayer.
- If you bought through a marketplace or with a card, check the dispute and return deadlines immediately.
- If you believe you were defrauded, report it to local law enforcement and the platform where you bought.
Red flags before you buy
- A price well below what established dealers charge for the same product.
- A seller who pushes for payment by wire to an individual, gift cards or cryptocurrency, with no buyer protection.
- Stock photos instead of photos of the actual items, or refusal to provide more photos.
- Bars from refiners you can't find on any refiner's official site, or serial numbers that repeat across listings.
- "Tube" or "monster box" lots sold privately at a discount, where every coin can't easily be checked.
- Pressure to decide quickly.
None of these prove a fake, but each is a reason to walk away or insist on verification first.
Buy formats that are easier to verify
Widely traded sovereign coins and bars from well-known refiners are easier for you and future buyers to check. That's part of why they resell easily; see which physical gold is easiest to resell. Larger bars may need more verification at sale time, which is discussed in kilo bar due diligence.
Frequently asked questions
Does a magnet test prove gold is real?
No. Gold isn't magnetic, so a coin that sticks to a magnet is fake, but many fake metals, including tungsten, are also non-magnetic. Use the magnet as one of several checks.
Can a fake gold coin weigh the right amount?
Yes. Tungsten is almost as dense as gold, so tungsten-core fakes can match both weight and size. Electronic testers or professional verification help with these.
Is acid testing safe for bullion?
Acid testing scratches and marks the item, which can reduce resale value. It's not recommended for coins or bars you plan to sell.
What is the best protection against fake gold?
Buying from established dealers with clear return policies, at prices consistent with the market. Most counterfeits are sold through private sales and marketplaces.
Why does my Gold Eagle weigh more than one ounce?
It's 22 karat. It contains one troy ounce of gold plus silver and copper alloy, for a gross weight of about 33.93 g. That's correct, not a sign of a problem.